1997 – Nate Vopata, (Madison Black Wolf)

1998 – Marc Gutfeld, (Sioux Falls Canaries)

1999 – Bryan Warner, (Duluth–Superior Dukes)

2000 – Jon Mueller, (Albany-Colonie Diamond Dogs)

2001 – Ryan Kane, (New Jersey Jackals)

2002 – Brent Sachs, (Winnipeg Goldeyes)

2003 – Cory Harris, (St. Paul Saints)

2004 – Chris Weekly, (Schaumburg Flyers)

2005 – Richard Austin, (Fargo-Moorhead RedHawks)

2006 – Stubby Clapp, (Edmonton Cracker-Cats)

2007 – Christian Snavely, (Schaumburg Flyers)

2008 – Jay Pecci, (Gary SouthShore RailCats)

2009 – Freddie Thon, (Joliet JackHammers)

2010 – Jason James, (Rockford RiverHawks)